Eurasianism and M. V. Shakhmatov (Distinction between Viewpoints Revisited)
https://doi.org/10.22162/2075-7794-2016-28-6-146-152
Abstract
The article is dedicated to emigrant historian M. V. Shakhmatov, the creator of the ‘State of Truth’ theory resulting from his analysis of ancient Russian literary and folklore compositions. Its basis was constituted by the concepts of sobornost (‘cooperation’), odinachestvo (‘equality’) and divine nature of political power. Despite present-day studies, it is quite difficult to consider it ‘Eurasianistic’ by nature though its author got a number his works printed in several volumes of the Eurasianists. In his papers there are no such ideas as the ‘outcome to the East’, decisive factor of development place, perception of Russia as Eurasia or the idea of struggle as the driving force of history; finally, there was no Eurasianistic understanding of the benefits of the Mongol invasion. Ideologists of Eurasianism considered M. V. Shakhmatov to be a temporary companion of theirs who was used merely as a ‘specialist’. In turn, he declared his break with them. In general, his views can be rather attributed to the revival of Slavophile ideas about the uniqueness of Russia’s historical path and its sharp contrast to the West. They stemmed not from the Eurasianistic movement but from personal searches in the course of work on a master’s thesis on the history of ancient political ideas.
The article analyzes M. V. Shakhmatov’s views, the circumstances of the appearance of his works in the Eurasianistic Vremennik, reflects the Eurasianists’ opinions about the author contained in the correspondence of G. V. Florovsky to N. S. Troubetzkoy, N. S. Troubetzkoy to P. P. Sovchinski. This correspondence has not been taken into account by previous researchers of M. V. Shakhmatov’s works which resulted in somewhat incorrect conclusions. Given the relevance of the study of Eurasianism as a whole, and the Eurasianistic concept of Russian history in particular, the distinction between viewpoints of M. V. Shakhmatov and Eurasianists will allow to avoid many errors in future publications. It may contribute to further detailed consideration of Eurasianistic compositions by representative of the 1920–1930s Russian emigration.
About the Author
Evgenii Derbin
Izhevsk State Agricultural Academy (Izhevsk, Russian Federation)
Russian Federation
Ph. D. in History, Associate Professor, Department of Russian History, Social and Political Studies, Izhevsk State Agricultural Academy (Izhevsk, Russian Federation)
Russian Federation
Ph. D. in History, Associate Professor, Department of Russian History, Social and Political Studies, Izhevsk State Agricultural Academy (Izhevsk, Russian Federation)
References
1. Alekseev N. N. Iz Tsar’grada v Pragu. Russkiy yuridicheskiy fakul’tet [From Tsargrad to Prague. Russian Faculty of Law]. Pashuto V. T. Russkie istoriki-emigranty v Evrope [Russian emigrant historians in Europe]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1991, pp. 205–224 (In Russ.).
2. Andreev N. E. To, chto vspominaetsya. Iz semeynykh vospominaniy Nikolaya Efremovicha Andreeva (1908–1982) [What is memorable. Excerpts from N. E. Andreev’s (1908–1982) family memoirs]. St. Petersburg, Dmitriy Bulanin Publ., 2008, 640 p. (In Russ.).
3. Savitsky P. N. Izbrannoe [Selected papers]. Moscow, ROSSPEN Publ., 2010, 776 p. (In Russ.).
4. Sobolev A. K voprosu o vnutrennikh treniyakh i protivorechiyakh v evraziystve 1920kh godov [On internal controversies and contradictions within the 1920s Eurasianism]. Rossiya XXI (Russia XXI journal), 2002, No. 5, pp. 166–196 (In Russ.).
5. Trubetskoy N. S. Pis’ma k P. P. Suvchinskomu: 1921–1928 [Letters to P. Suvchinsky: 1921–1928]. Moscow, Russkoe Zarubezhye Foundation, Rus. Put Publ., 384 p. (In Russ.).
6. Shakhmatov M. V. Gosudarstvo pravdy [The State of Truth]. Moscow, FondIV Publ., 2008, 312 p. (In Russ.).
7. Shakhmatov M. V. Opyty po istorii drevnerusskikh politicheskikh idey. T. 1. Ucheniya russkikh letopisey domongol’skogo perioda o gosudarstvennoy vlasti. Praga, 1926. Kn. 1. Nachalo sobornosti; Praga, 1927. Kn. 2. Nachalo edinolichnoy vlasti. 575 s. [Revisiting Old Russian political ideas …] (In Russ.).
8. Shakhmatov M. V. Samobytnichestvo i lyubov’ k Otechestvu [Authenticity and love for Motherland]. Vozrozhdenie [The Revival journal], 1925, No. 153, 160, 174 (In Russ.).
9. Vandalkovskaya M. G. Istoricheskaya nauka rossiyskoy emigratsii: «evraziyskiy soblazn» [Historical studies within the Russian expatriate community: ‘temptation of Eurasianism’]. Moscow, Pamyatniki Ist. Mysli Publ., 1997, 350 p. (In Russ.).
10. Vandalkovskaya M. G. Istoricheskaya nauka rossiyskoy emigratsii (1920–1930-e gg.) [Historical studies within the Russian expatriate community (1920–1930s)]. Ocherki istorii otechestvennoy istoricheskoy nauki XX veka / Pod red. V. P. Korzun [Sketches on the history of Russian historical studies in the 20th c. Edit. by V. Korzun]. Omsk, Omsk State Univ. Press, 2005, pp. 397–435 (In Russ.).
11. Vasilyev A. A. Evraziyskaya kontseptsiya gosudarstva pravdy M. V. Shakhmatova [M. Shakhmatov’s Eurasianistic concept of the ‘State of Truth’]. Evraziystvo: teoreticheskiy potentsial i prakticheskie prilozheniya: materialy Shestoy Vserossiyskoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii (s mezhdunarodnym uchastiem) [Eurasianism: Theoretical Potential and Practical Application. Proc. of the 6th all-Russia research and practice conf. (Barnaul, 25–26 June 2012), in 2 vol.] Barnaul, 2012, vol. 1, pp.78–82 (In Russ.).
12. Vasilyev A. A. Kontseptsiya gosudarstva pravdy i tsarya-podvigopolozhnika M. V. Shakhmatova [M. Shakhmatov’s concept of the ‘State of Truth’ and self-sacrificing Tsar]. Gosudarstvennaya vlast’ i mestnoe samoupravlenie [State-Power and Local Self-Government journal], 2013, No. 5, pp. 6–9 (In Russ.).
13. Gacheva A. G. Ideya «Tret’ey Rossii» i porevolyutsionnye techeniya russkoy emigratsii [The idea of a ‘Third Russia’ and post-revolutionary movements within the Russian expatriate community]. V poiskakh novoy ideologii: Sotsiokul’turnye aspekty russkogo literaturnogo protsessa 1920–1930-kh godov [In search of a new ideology: socio-cultural aspects of the Russian literary process in the 1920–1930s]. Moscow, 2010, pp. 375–422 (In Russ.).
14. Demina L., Mokhnacheva M. Shakhmatov Mstislav Vyacheslavovich [Mstislav V. Shakhmatov]. Russkoe zarubezh’e. Zolotaya kniga emigratsii. Pervaya tret’ XX veka: Ents. biogr. slov. [Russian expatriate community. Gold book of the emigration. Biographical dictionary]. Moscow, ROSSPEN Publ., 1997, p. 711 (In Russ.).
15. Kovalev M. V. Istoricheskaya pamyat’ i identichnost’ rossiyskoy emigratsii 1920 — 1930-kh godov: ocherki [Historical memory and identity of Russian expatriates, 1920–1930s]. Saratov, Sarat. State Technical Univ. Press, 2013, 204 p. (In Russ.).
16. Kovalev M. V. Russkie istoriki-emigranty v Prage (1920–1940 gg.) [Russian emigrant historians in Prague (1920–1940s)]. Saratov, Sarat. State Technical Univ. Press, 2012, 408 p. (In Russ.).
17. Malyavin S. N. Istoriya russkoy sotsial’no-filosofskoy mysli [History of Russian socio-philosophical thought]. Moscow, Drofa Publ., 2003, 256 p. (In Russ.).
18. Maslin M. A. «Evraziyskie vremenniki» kak istochnik klassicheskogo evraziystva [Evraziyskie Vremenniki as a source of the classical Eurasianism]. Evraziyskaya ideya i sovremennost’ [Eurasianism and contemporaneity]. Moscow, RUDN Press, 2002, pp. 245–253 (In Russ.).
19. Nazmutdinov B. V. Politiko-pravovye vozzreniya evraziytsev v rossiyskom gosudarstvovedenii XX veka [Political and legislative views of Eurasianists in the 20th c. Russian political studies]. Moscow, Higher School of Economics Press, 2013, 247 p. (In Russ.).
20. Smolin M. B. Istoricheskaya spravka ob avtore knigi [A historical note about the author]. Shakhmatov M. V. Gosudarstvo pravdy [The State of Truth]. Moscow, FondIV Publ., 2008, pp. 306–307 (In Russ.).
21. Sorokina M. Yu. Rossiyskoe nauchnoe zarubezh’e: materialy dlya biobibliograficheskogo slovarya. Vyp. 4: Yuridicheskie nauki: XIX — pervaya polovina XX v. [Russian expatriate scientific community: materials for a bibliographic dictionary. Iss. 4: legal sciences …]. Moscow, Solzhenitsyn Centre of Russian Emigré Studies Press, 2011, 220 p. (In Russ.).
22. Suslov A. A. «Gosudarstvo pravdy» v trudakh M. V. Shakhmatova i N. N. Alekseeva [The ‘State of Truth’ in M. Shakhmatov’s and N. Alekseev’s works]. Svobodnaya mysl’ [The Free Thought journal], 2007, No. 7, pp. 180–191 (In Russ.).
23. Suslov A. A. Russkie politicheskie idealy v evraziyskoy istoriosofii: obraz «gosudarstva pravdy» [Russian political ideals: image of the ‘State of Truth’]. Vestnik RGGU. Seriya: Filosofiya. Sotsiologiya. Iskusstvovedenie [RGGU Bulletin], 2008, No. 7, pp. 174–185 (In Russ.).
24. Khachaturyan V. M. Kul’tura Evrazii: etnos i geopolitika [Culture of Eurasia: ethnos and geopolitics]. Evraziyskaya ideya i sovremennost’ [Eurasianism and contemporaneity]. Moscow, RUDN Press, 2002, pp. 98–104 (In Russ.).
25. Tsepilova V. I. Istoricheskaya nauka russkogo zarubezh’ya: problemy istoriografii (1920–2004 gg.) [Historical studies within the Russian expatriate community: problems of historiography (1920–2004)]. Ekaterinburg, Ural State Univ. Press, 2005, 294 p. (In Russ.).
Review
For citations:
Derbin E. Eurasianism and M. V. Shakhmatov (Distinction between Viewpoints Revisited). Oriental Studies. 2016;9(6):146-152. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22162/2075-7794-2016-28-6-146-152
Views:
509
Email this article 